Birdsong

Daniel Schonning

"Place cannot be body," writes Aristotle,". . .qua containing, it is different from the matter." He'srestating one of Zeno's paradoxes. Putsimply: the cicada's shell is notthe insect, even while it's worn. But what you and Iunderstand, reader, is that place makes a body. Thevesper iris is named not only forwhen it blooms, but also where—along the marblexyst of a far-off monastery, its blue lipsyawn open (for a moment) to receive the evening prayer. Are its dark inner folds place? Its green stalk?Zeno would say no. In his vision of place, nothing grows; a child walking home neverarrives; arrows stall and dissolve mid-flight—their ghosts thickening the summer air likebirdsong. But, reader, we know the world to be otherwise. See how the Kentucky warbler's brittleclutch of new-laid eggs curls opposite the nest's round palm. Who firstdrew together the debris of a space—bound theeven-threaded twigs and pale strips of bark, the dryferns andgrasses—into a world-made womb? Who chose the first lonely crook ofhawthorn or honeysuckle on which to settle and create?I must stop to tell you, reader, as I've onlyjust learned: If a cowbird lays its eggs in that same nest, aKentucky warbler will simply build another over top.Left underneath, the eggs—warbler and cowbird, both—might yet hatch, might tremble and call out. But they have already ceased to be bodies.Now, in their dark net of tree and reed, they are partof place—are only womb through which the next clutch comes.

Feature Date

Series

Selected By

Share This Poem

Print This Poem

photo of Daniel Schonning
Photo:
Cherie Nelson

Daniel Schonning’s poems have appeared in Orion Magazine, The Yale Review, Poetry Magazine, and elsewhere. His poem “Aleph with all, all with Aleph” was selected by judge Cyrus Cassells as winner of Crazyhorse’s 2020 Lynda Hull Memorial Prize. He lives in Geneva, New York, where he serves as the Trias Postgraduate Teaching Fellow at Hobart and William Smith Colleges and as Reviews Editor for Seneca Review.

Cover of the Carolina Quarterly

Spring/Summer 2021

Chapel Hill, North Carolina

UNC Chapel Hill

Editor-in-Chief
Ellie Rambo

Poetry Editor
Colin Dekeersgieter

Managing Editor
Amy Chan

The Carolina Quarterly publishes a variety of poetry, fiction, essays, reviews, and artwork twice a year and is distributed to readers locally and to individual subscribers, public and university libraries, and bookstores in the United States and worldwide. Back issues are sold throughout the year. Free online access to the full-text of our current and back issues is available through the academic databases, EBSCO and ProQuest.

The Carolina Quarterly has been publishing established and emergent writers for 65 years. Recent issues have featured the works of Lauri Anderson, James Gordon Bennett, Megan Mayhew Bergman, Sean Bishop, Nicole Terez Dutton, Aaron Gwyn, K.A. Hays, Caitlin Horrocks, Stuart Nadler, Ben Purkert, Valerie Sayers, Ken Taylor, Matthew Volmer, G.C. Waldrep, Jerald Walker, and more. Pieces published in The Carolina Quarterly have appeared in New Stories from the South, Best of the South, Poetry Daily, O. Henry Prize Stories, The Pushcart Prizes, and Best American Short Stories.

Poetry Daily Depends on You

With your support, we make reading the best contemporary poetry a treasured daily experience. Consider a contribution today.